Looking back on it, Obamacare was inevitable, because President Obama made it so. Regardless of the hurdles, the absurdities of the Democrats, the rage of the Republicans and the dollars of the corporations, he was going to exert every ounce of his power and determination until the Affordable Care Act happened.
Likewise, I believe that at some point Planned Parenthood will be defunded. Roe v. Wade has been red meat for stupid people since it happened in 1973; politicians and corporations have been tossing it to them knowing it would guarantee power. It took little time to create the shorthand equating Planned Parenthood with abortion with baby-killing.
Until we want our reproductive freedom more than the crazy people want to deny us, we will continue to roll down that hill to the inevitable crash.
Because the fight is not about what is rational. Whoever organized the surveillance, the editing and distorting of the tapes and the gradual and cleverly planned distribution over the internet and feeding of the media, knew that facts had nothing to do with their cause. Just as the ACORN blitzkrieg was orchestrated during the 2008 election season, the Planned Parenthood demolition was scheduled for the current presidential election season. Whether PP is taken down or not, all the buzz is about the nonchalance over killing babies, and the money scandal is just the topping (the ironic cherry if you will) on the icky mess.
We may have candidates like Bernie and Hillary that can win despite this mammoth publicity stunt, but Planned Parenthood will have to continue to fight until the day our not-so-mighty Congress glady (republican) or timidly (democrat) vote to defund. Possibly even worse, Democrats will give in to budget cuts, destroying Planned Parenthood with a death by a thousand cuts. Which has already begun.
When you Google Planned Parenthood, today the news headline is that "due to the increased questions" about PP, a major human tissue firm has cut ties. After the Wikipedia entry and PP's own Stand with Planned Parenthood page comes "Planned Parenthood Exposed". Then our own NPR, itself under constant siege, grabs readers with Ben Carson's accusation on for-god's-sake Fox News that Planned Parenthood is an attempt to control the poor black population. Like he cares. But if Fox News can play the "Fair and Balanced" game, so can NPR.
While Planned Parenthood is fighting for its life, and trying to fight while appearing not to lose its head, why are the rest of us debating this bullshit? I've heard Democrats calmly talk about the indiscretion of the PP employees caught on the doctored tape, or wondering why opponents just don't understand the importance of fetal tissue in health research, or defending PP because of course they are not "selling" fetal tissue for profit. And then there is the fact that abortion is a legal procedure, which at this point in our fragile existence is the staunches defense being presented.
Bullshit. The reason the anti-abortion brigade is not swayed by reason is because this is not about reason. Some holding the pitchforks are screaming "god" and "faith." Others are outraged about tax dollars whether or not they are being used on abortions because, well, they are being used for poor people. And then of course there are those who spit out "Planned Parenthood" the way they mutter "Obama."
Fact is, we should leave the rational arguments to Planned Parenthood. What we should be fighting about is the sneaking, spying, lying and conniving being done to this organization. If the government was doing it, it would be considered entrapment and thrown out. But because it is not a government investigation which would theoretically have to follow rules of ethics, this campaign of deceit is allowed to proceed, unquestioned and unchecked, cheered on by right-wing politicians, to annihilate another lifeline to women.
And we can count on the media to lead with the headlines provided by this sleazy front, without wasting time or money to investigate this attack on this women's health care organization.
So we are left with nonsense, but nonsense filled with incendiary words and accusations that will be repeated throughout the coming year. The threat of losing Planned Parenthood will be another of those battles we must waste time chasing rather than attacking the corporations that have bought our politicians and our country.
This fight is ugly. There are no rules. As long as we attempt to be reasonable we are going to slowly but inevitably lose. We should be outraged. Men should be outraged that their families are being assaulted. Women should be in a fury over the attempt to control their bodies; the attempt to end Planned Parenthood is a symbol, because once that goes the battle to end not just abortion but birth control will proceed with full speed, the warriors vitalized. And that tool Ben Carson has it half right: it is about poor African Americans, but it is his side that is destroying their lives and livelihoods. It is about women -- and men -- being unable to determine their financial security, to care for themselves and their families, to pursue college and career without fear of disruption. It is about a woman not having to cower when she is attacked, but being able to fight back and take back control of her life. It is about not having to hide in the shadows, living hand to mouth, and it is about not having to go back to the back-alley abortions, coat hangers and poisons of the days before Roe v. Wade.
It is about unlawful surveillance, it is about lying and misrepresentation, the weasels responsible for it and the media that repeats the lies. We have let our legislators get away with proposing to invade our privacy at a time when those same legislators are defending the right to carry a gun without restriction. We have been moving toward ever greater surveillance and threats to a woman's right to live in her body without interference while guns can be carried without fear of reprisal.
I am not going to be arguing about whether those conversations should have happened, doctored or not. It is the surveillance and lying that should not have happened. These are the crimes that should be investigated and prosecuted.
We lost ACORN and the enemies of our freedom said, "Job well done." We may not lose Planned Parenthood right away. Hillary may be defending it today. But over time, when the screams and threats of the attackers get louder rather than subside, even Hillary will make concessions to the rage and the hatred. Because it is scary and it doesn't stop.
I hope I am wrong, but I am not seeing the outrage and passion we need to win this war. Our elected officials need to join us in getting as apoplectic about the invasion of privacy in affairs of women's reproduction as republicans throwing red meat out at those voyeurs who harass women in front of abortion clinics.
Showing posts with label Roe v. Wade. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Roe v. Wade. Show all posts
Saturday, August 15, 2015
Sunday, June 28, 2015
Supreme's Greatest Hits
The Supreme Court seems to have ended its session and begun summer vacation with a bang. Three major decisions over the past several days have reflected what I heard one commentator refer to as the most "liberal" court in decades.
To which I did a double take. But when I thought about it, we did have some really significant wins.
The surprise decision was the one that supported the Fair Housing Act of 1968. Surprising in light of the demolition of the Voting Rights Act, which gave states the right the do whatever damn thing they wanted to keep selected groups from voting, and which they wasted no time following through. Chief Justice John Roberts, with his Pollyanna smile, declared there was no need for voting rights protection because racism was dead. Leaving me wondering what rationalizations he made to justify the red-state rush to legalize voter discrimination immediately after the decision.
Not one to ever learn from his mistakes, Roberts was one of the four who voted against supporting the Fair Housing Act. But he did weigh in with us liberals on the case that had my heart beating fast. The state health care exchanges, with federal subsidies, remained intact, leaving a lot of folks like me with our Obamacare. The vote was 6-3, with the core group of idiots, Scalia, Thomas and Alito holding down the right wing-nut opinion.
For those of you who are thinking Roberts may be sliding to the left, his opinion had nothing to do with the rights of Americans to have affordable health care. His decision, just like the one in favor of Obamacare three years ago, was purely pro-business. If you recall back then Roberts' opinion had pretty much everybody's head spinning, including his own. He twisted and corkscrewed the law, arguing not the obvious one that was in question regarding the Commerce Clause, but that the individual mandate was a tax, and the feds were within their constitutional right to levy that tax.
So. I'm thinking Roberts knew quite well that the insurance industry would take a crippling blow if it lost all us customers that could no longer afford health insurance without the federal subsidies. And there are quite a lot of us.
Scalia, on the other hand, and despite his contention that his decisions are based purely on constitutional originalism, consistently bases his decision on what feels good to him. This is the guy, after all, who believes that the devil is a real person. So let's assume logic doesn't have as much to do with his thinking process as he would like us to believe.
Along with his imaginings of the devil and what the founding fathers believed we should be doing all these years later, Scalia has the kind of rigid and fragile psyche that just can't take much confrontation. And so when he writes his dissents (which Chris Hayes noted are extremely wonderful and entertaining, especially because they are dissents) he tends not to sound all that educated, or intelligent, or even rational.
In his dissenting opinion on the Obamacare decision he calls the majority opinion "interpretive jiggery-pokery" and "pure applesauce," legal terms that no doubt go back to the founding fathers. He snipes that since the Court has backed Obamacare in two major decisions, "we should start calling this law SCOTUScare." And in an overwrought, pubescent and melodramatic fit, he sums it up by saying, "Words no longer have meaning...."
Roberts predictably let his right-wing flag fly in the marriage equality decision. No surprise there. It was purely a human rights case, and human rights will not sway our Chief Justice. And I was not at all surprised that Kennedy was the deciding vote in favor of marriage equality, as he has voted in favor of gay rights before.
I'm thinking that a couple of things are happening with the Supremes. Justice Kennedy retains his position as the swing vote. I believe that he is a romantic, and he likes to feel like he is being wooed. It also seems to me that he is easily influenced by the new guys on the block. It happened when Roberts and Alito took up the cause of the right a decade ago, and now we have the left-leaning Kagan and Sotomayor.
Roberts is going to vote pro-business and against human rights. The only individual he is going to support is the individual corporation.
The most fun these days is watching the narcissistic Scalia as he comes apart at the seams. And even better, the more that happens, the less likely Kennedy is likely to want to be seen siding with him, leaving him sitting alone at the cafeteria table with Clarence Thomas and Sammy Alito.
Without taking away from these important victories, though, I am concerned about one group of decisions, those affecting women's privacy and health care rights. Hobby Lobby, which has never blinked about paying for insurance that covers vasectomies, won the right to deny women contraceptive coverage. Even Kagan and Sotomayor voted against a woman's right to be safe from harassment at an abortion clinic, refusing to support a state's right to determine an appropriate buffer zone from protesters.
At this point, with state and federal legislators pushing ever more extreme anti-abortion bills into law, pro-choice groups are afraid to take a case to this Supreme Court, fearing the complete overturn of Roe v. Wade. This could happen, but we need to take our cue from the fearlessness and persistence of the LGBT community. We need to continue to take cases to the Supremes, and we need to find new arguments, just as Burwell did with Obamacare. We can't stop fighting, and we can't let our worry about the bias of all those Catholics on the bench slow us down or even cause us to hesitate. As disappointed as I have been in the women's reproductive health care decisions, it is only by showing our strength that they will eventually be swayed.
So have a good summer vacation, Supremes. We are counting on you to keep us entertained next time around.
To which I did a double take. But when I thought about it, we did have some really significant wins.
The surprise decision was the one that supported the Fair Housing Act of 1968. Surprising in light of the demolition of the Voting Rights Act, which gave states the right the do whatever damn thing they wanted to keep selected groups from voting, and which they wasted no time following through. Chief Justice John Roberts, with his Pollyanna smile, declared there was no need for voting rights protection because racism was dead. Leaving me wondering what rationalizations he made to justify the red-state rush to legalize voter discrimination immediately after the decision.
Not one to ever learn from his mistakes, Roberts was one of the four who voted against supporting the Fair Housing Act. But he did weigh in with us liberals on the case that had my heart beating fast. The state health care exchanges, with federal subsidies, remained intact, leaving a lot of folks like me with our Obamacare. The vote was 6-3, with the core group of idiots, Scalia, Thomas and Alito holding down the right wing-nut opinion.
For those of you who are thinking Roberts may be sliding to the left, his opinion had nothing to do with the rights of Americans to have affordable health care. His decision, just like the one in favor of Obamacare three years ago, was purely pro-business. If you recall back then Roberts' opinion had pretty much everybody's head spinning, including his own. He twisted and corkscrewed the law, arguing not the obvious one that was in question regarding the Commerce Clause, but that the individual mandate was a tax, and the feds were within their constitutional right to levy that tax.
So. I'm thinking Roberts knew quite well that the insurance industry would take a crippling blow if it lost all us customers that could no longer afford health insurance without the federal subsidies. And there are quite a lot of us.
Scalia, on the other hand, and despite his contention that his decisions are based purely on constitutional originalism, consistently bases his decision on what feels good to him. This is the guy, after all, who believes that the devil is a real person. So let's assume logic doesn't have as much to do with his thinking process as he would like us to believe.
Along with his imaginings of the devil and what the founding fathers believed we should be doing all these years later, Scalia has the kind of rigid and fragile psyche that just can't take much confrontation. And so when he writes his dissents (which Chris Hayes noted are extremely wonderful and entertaining, especially because they are dissents) he tends not to sound all that educated, or intelligent, or even rational.
In his dissenting opinion on the Obamacare decision he calls the majority opinion "interpretive jiggery-pokery" and "pure applesauce," legal terms that no doubt go back to the founding fathers. He snipes that since the Court has backed Obamacare in two major decisions, "we should start calling this law SCOTUScare." And in an overwrought, pubescent and melodramatic fit, he sums it up by saying, "Words no longer have meaning...."
Roberts predictably let his right-wing flag fly in the marriage equality decision. No surprise there. It was purely a human rights case, and human rights will not sway our Chief Justice. And I was not at all surprised that Kennedy was the deciding vote in favor of marriage equality, as he has voted in favor of gay rights before.
I'm thinking that a couple of things are happening with the Supremes. Justice Kennedy retains his position as the swing vote. I believe that he is a romantic, and he likes to feel like he is being wooed. It also seems to me that he is easily influenced by the new guys on the block. It happened when Roberts and Alito took up the cause of the right a decade ago, and now we have the left-leaning Kagan and Sotomayor.
Roberts is going to vote pro-business and against human rights. The only individual he is going to support is the individual corporation.
The most fun these days is watching the narcissistic Scalia as he comes apart at the seams. And even better, the more that happens, the less likely Kennedy is likely to want to be seen siding with him, leaving him sitting alone at the cafeteria table with Clarence Thomas and Sammy Alito.
Without taking away from these important victories, though, I am concerned about one group of decisions, those affecting women's privacy and health care rights. Hobby Lobby, which has never blinked about paying for insurance that covers vasectomies, won the right to deny women contraceptive coverage. Even Kagan and Sotomayor voted against a woman's right to be safe from harassment at an abortion clinic, refusing to support a state's right to determine an appropriate buffer zone from protesters.
At this point, with state and federal legislators pushing ever more extreme anti-abortion bills into law, pro-choice groups are afraid to take a case to this Supreme Court, fearing the complete overturn of Roe v. Wade. This could happen, but we need to take our cue from the fearlessness and persistence of the LGBT community. We need to continue to take cases to the Supremes, and we need to find new arguments, just as Burwell did with Obamacare. We can't stop fighting, and we can't let our worry about the bias of all those Catholics on the bench slow us down or even cause us to hesitate. As disappointed as I have been in the women's reproductive health care decisions, it is only by showing our strength that they will eventually be swayed.
So have a good summer vacation, Supremes. We are counting on you to keep us entertained next time around.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)